The Pros and Cons of Deferring Property Taxes: A Canadian Homeowner's Guide

Deferring property taxes allows qualifying homeowners to postpone paying their annual property taxes, essentially taking a loan from the government that is repaid later, typically when the home is sold. This article explores the pros and cons of deferring property taxes, drawing heavily on the example of British Columbia's long-standing program to help you understand if this option is right for you.

What is Property Tax Deferral?

Property tax deferral programs are designed to help homeowners manage their tax obligations without immediate payment. Since 1974, British Columbia has offered a Provincial Property Tax Deferral Program (PTD). This program isn't a single entity; it comprises two main streams: the Regular Program, aimed at those 55 and older, surviving spouses, and persons with disabilities, and another program specifically for families with children under 18. Despite its potential benefits, awareness and uptake of these programs have historically been limited, partly due to a generational aversion to debt among seniors.

How Does Property Tax Deferral Work in B.C.?

If you qualify for the B.C. PTD program, the provincial government pays your residential property taxes directly to your municipality on your behalf. This amount becomes a loan registered against your property. You are required to repay this loan, along with accumulated interest, when you eventually sell the home, or you can choose to repay it sooner. A one-time administration fee (e.g., $60) is typically charged for new agreements, with a smaller annual renewal fee (e.g., $10) added to the deferred amount each year you continue in the program.

Calculate your taxes with our free tax calculator.

Use our IRPF 2024 calculator to quickly calculate your tax refund or the amount you owe.

Calculate >

Who Qualifies for Deferral?

General qualifications for the B.C. Regular PTD program typically require you to be a registered owner of the home, using it as your principal residence. You must meet age requirements (55 or older during the calendar year of application), be a surviving spouse, or qualify as a person with disabilities. Other requirements include being a Canadian citizen or permanent resident, having lived in B.C. for at least a year prior to applying, having paid all previous property-related debts, and maintaining a minimum equity of 25%in your home based on its assessed value. A current fire insurance policy is also necessary; without it, eligibility might be based only on land value, potentially disqualifying manufactured homeowners without land ownership.

The Pros of Deferring Property Taxes

Choosing to defer property taxes can offer significant advantages, making it an attractive option for many homeowners under the right circumstances.

Significant Financial Relief

The most direct benefit is immediate cash flow relief. For retirees or families facing tight budgets, deferring a large annual property tax bill can free up necessary funds for daily living expenses. This aligns with the original intent of many deferral programs: helping homeowners, particularly seniors and those with disabilities, remain in their homes without facing undue financial hardship due to property taxes.

Extremely Low Interest Costs

A major draw, particularly for the B.C. Regular PTD program, is the exceptionally low interest rate. For example, rates have been cited as low as 0.70% or even 0.45%. Crucially, this is typically simple interest, not compound interest, meaning you don't pay interest on previously accrued interest. This makes the cost of borrowing significantly lower than most other forms of credit. The rate is usually tied to the province's borrowing cost, often set at a maximum like 2% below that rate, and reviewed semi-annually.

No Means Test

Interestingly, programs like the B.C. PTD often lack a means test. This means eligibility is based on factors like age, residency, and home equity, not income level. While designed to assist those struggling financially, this opens the door for higher-net-worth individuals to use the program strategically, perhaps viewing the low-interest loan as an advantageous financial tool or even a "tax loophole".

Strategic Use of Funds

Deferring taxes frees up capital that can be potentially used for other financial goals. Homeowners might redirect the funds they would have spent on taxes towards:

• Topping up a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA).
• Making contributions to a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), especially if still earning income.
• Investing in a non-registered account, aiming for returns higher than the deferral interest rate.
• Funding a life insurance policy to enhance estate value.

If the potential return on these alternative uses exceeds the low cost of the deferral interest, it can be a financially savvy move.

The Cons of Deferring Property Taxes

Despite the benefits, deferring property taxes comes with potential drawbacks and risks that homeowners must carefully consider.

Accumulating Debt

The most significant downside is the accumulation of debt. While the interest rate is low, the deferred taxes and the simple interest add up year after year. For example, deferring an initial $5,000 annual tax bill at 0.70% interest, assuming a 5% annual tax increase, could result in a total debt (principal and interest) of over $65,000 after 10 years. Deferring a $10,000 initial bill under the same assumptions could lead to over $130,000 owed. This growing liability reduces the net equity available when the home is eventually sold.

Lien on Property

When you defer taxes, a restrictive lien is registered against your property title. This secures the loan for the government and must be cleared before the property title can be legally transferred to a new owner (except in specific cases like transfer to a surviving spouse). While standard practice for secured loans, some homeowners may be uncomfortable with this encumbrance.

Variable Interest Rates

Although current interest rates may be very low, there is no guarantee they will remain so indefinitely. Rates are typically reviewed periodically (e.g., every six months). An increase in the interest rate would increase the overall cost of deferral over the long term.

Potential Application Issues

There's a risk associated with the application process. If your application for deferral isn't submitted correctly or isn't approved, and the property tax due date passes, you could be charged **late payment penalties** by your municipality.

Underlying Financial Health

Deferring taxes can be a valuable tool, but it's important to consider why deferral is being sought. As noted in the reference text, if the primary reason is an inability to afford the taxes, it might indicate a need to review the overall household budget. Relying on deferral might mask deeper financial issues that need addressing.

Deferral vs. Arbitrage: A Broader Perspective

The reference material also touches upon a nuanced point comparing tax deferral mechanisms like RRSPs and TFSAs. It distinguishes between tax deferral (delaying tax payment) and tax arbitrage (shifting income to be taxed at a lower rate). While property tax deferral primarily offers the benefit of delaying payment at a low cost, the broader concept reminds us that deferral itself isn't always advantageous if tax rates remain the same or increase in the future.

However, the extremely low simple interest rate associated with programs like B.C.'s PTD often makes the cost of this specific type of deferral highly attractive compared to other financial options or deferral mechanisms.

Making the Right Decision

Deciding whether to defer property taxes is a significant financial decision. The B.C. PTD program clearly fulfills its purpose of helping homeowners, particularly seniors, manage expenses and stay in their homes. For those who qualify and have alternative, potentially higher-return uses for their cash, the low simple interest rate makes deferral a compelling financial strategy. However, the prospect of accumulating debt and placing a lien on one's home causes hesitation for many, especially those averse to debt.

As suggested, consulting with family members or a trusted financial advisor is prudent. They can help assess your individual circumstances, budget, long-term goals, and risk tolerance to determine if exploring the pros and cons of deferring property taxes leads to the conclusion that it's the right choice for you.

Conclusion

In summary, deferring property taxes offers the primary pro of immediate cash flow relief facilitated by a government loan, often at a very low simple interest rate, without requiring a means test. This can be crucial for managing expenses or strategically deploying funds elsewhere. The main cons include the steady accumulation of debt against home equity, the placement of a lien on the property, the uncertainty of future interest rates, and the potential to mask underlying budget issues. Ultimately, weighing these pros and cons of deferring property taxes requires careful consideration of your personal financial situation and long-term objectives.

Have you considered deferring your property taxes, and what factors are most important in your decision?

Property Tax Deferment Usage Example (B.C. - Vancouver Island 2020 Cumulative Data)

The following table illustrates the cumulative uptake of the Property Tax Deferment program in various Vancouver Island jurisdictions as of 2020, showing the number of households participating and the total amount of taxes deferred over time.

If you want to know other articles similar to The Pros and Cons of Deferring Property Taxes: A Canadian Homeowner's Guidey ou can visit the category Tax Planning and Optimization.