Understanding the Tax Treaty Between the Philippines and Canada

The tax treaty between the Philippines and Canada is a bilateral agreement designed to prevent double taxation and fiscal evasion related to income taxes for individuals and entities that are residents of either Canada or the Philippines. It clarifies taxing rights and provides mechanisms for resolving disputes and exchanging information between the two countries' tax authorities. The treaty covers various types of income, including business profits, dividends, interest, royalties, capital gains, and income from personal services.

Personal Scope and Taxes Covered (Articles I & II)

The treaty's application is clearly defined. Article I, "Personal Scope," states that the Convention applies to "persons who are residents of one or both of the Contracting States." This means the treaty's benefits and provisions are generally available to individuals, companies, and other entities considered residents of either Canada or the Philippines, or both. It sets a broad initial scope.

Article II, "Taxes Covered," specifies the types of taxes to which the agreement applies. It encompasses "taxes on income imposed on behalf of each Contracting State," regardless of how they are levied. This includes all taxes on total income or elements of income, such as those on capital gains and wages. Specifically, it mentions "income taxes imposed by the Government of Canada" (Canadian tax) and "income taxes imposed by the Government of the Republic of the Philippines" (Philippine tax). Importantly, the Convention also extends to any "identical or substantially similar taxes on income" imposed after the treaty's signing, ensuring its continued relevance.

Calculate your taxes with our free tax calculator.

Use our IRPF 2024 calculator to quickly calculate your tax refund or the amount you owe.

Calculate >

Defining Residency: Fiscal Domicile (Article IV)

Determining residency is crucial for applying the treaty's provisions. Article IV, "Fiscal Domicile," defines a "resident of a Contracting State" as any person liable to taxation in that state "by reason of his domicile, residence, place of management or any other criterion of a similar nature." This establishes a broad definition based on a person's connection to a country. However, complexities arise when an individual or company is considered a resident of both countries under their respective domestic laws.

To resolve dual residency, the treaty provides tie-breaker rules. For individuals, a hierarchy of criteria is applied, starting with a "permanent home," then "centre of vital interests" (personal and economic relations), "habitual abode," and finally, nationality. If nationality doesn't resolve the issue, the competent authorities of both countries must settle the matter by mutual agreement. For companies, residency is initially determined by nationality. If the company is not a national of either state, the competent authorities again step in to reach a mutual agreement.

Permanent Establishment (Article V): A Key Concept

The concept of a "permanent establishment" (PE) is fundamental in international taxation and is thoroughly addressed in Article V. A PE is essentially a fixed place of business through which an enterprise carries out its activities. The existence of a PE in one country generally allows that country to tax the profits attributable to that PE.

The treaty provides a detailed definition, including specific examples like a place of management, branch, office, factory, workshop, and extraction sites. Construction or assembly projects lasting more than a specified time (six months for building/construction, three months for assembly) also constitute a PE. Premises used as sales outlets and, in certain conditions, warehouses, are included. However, the treaty also lists exceptions – activities considered preparatory or auxiliary, such as storage, display, or delivery of goods, and the purchase of goods or collection of information, do not create a PE.

The article goes further explaining that a person acting in one state on behalf of an enterprise of the other state. Excluding an independent agent, will be considered a permanent stablishment if the person in question can conclude contracts or mantains a stock of goods of the enterprise.

Even an insurance enterprise can be deemed to have a permanent establishment, except in regard to re-insurance.

Taxation of Specific Income Types

The treaty addresses the taxation of various income categories, allocating taxing rights between Canada and the Philippines based on the source of the income and the residency of the recipient. Key articles include:

Income from Immovable Property (Article VI)

Income from immovable property (real estate), including agriculture and forestry, can be taxed in the country where the property is located. The definition of "immovable property" is based on the law of the country where the property is situated. This includes associated property, livestock, and rights related to landed property.

Business Profits (Article VII)

Business profits of an enterprise are generally taxable only in the enterprise's country of residence, *unless* it has a PE in the other country. If a PE exists, the profits attributable to that PE can be taxed in the country where the PE is located. The treaty also allows taxation of profits from sales or business activities similar to those conducted through the PE. Attributable profits are determined as if the PE were a distinct and separate enterprise. Deductible expenses, including executive and general administrative expenses, are allowed.

Shipping and Air Transport (Article VIII)

Profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic are generally taxable only in the enterprise's country of residence. However, profits from sources within a Contracting State may be taxed in that State, but the tax is limited to the lesser of 1.5% of gross revenues or the lowest rate of Philippine tax imposed on similar profits of an enterprise from a third state.

Associated Enterprises (Article IX)

This article addresses transfer pricing issues. If transactions between associated enterprises (e.g., parent and subsidiary companies) are not conducted at arm's length (i.e., under conditions that would prevail between independent enterprises), profits can be adjusted and taxed accordingly. This prevents artificial shifting of profits to reduce tax liability. An appropriate adjustment can be made by the other state, and changes must be done within the time limit of national law, and five years in any case. This does not apply for fraud cases.

Dividends (Article X)

Dividends paid by a company resident in one country to a resident of the other country can be taxed in both countries. However, the tax rate in the source country is limited. If the beneficial owner is a resident of the Philippines, dividend paid by a company which is resident of Canada can be taxed up to 15% of the gross amount.
If the beneficial owner is a resident of Canada, dividend paid by a company which is resident of the Philippines can be taxed up to: 15% of the gross amount of any dividend paid to a company which is a resident of Canada and controls 10% of the company, or 25% in all other cases.

Interest (Article XI)

Similar to dividends, interest arising in one country and paid to a resident of the other can be taxed in both. The tax rate in the source country is limited to 15% of the gross amount, provided the interest is taxable in the other Contracting State. The definition of "interest" is broad, covering income from debt-claims of various kinds. There are exceptions for interest on government bonds and loans guaranteed by specific entities (e.g., the Export Development Corporation in Canada), which may be taxable only in the recipient's country of residence. The Philippine tax on interest of public issues can not exceed 10%.

Royalties (Article XII)

Royalties, like dividends and interest, can be taxed in both countries. The source country's tax rate is limited. In Canada it is 10% of the gross amount of the royalties. In the Philippines, the lesser of 25% of the gross amount or the lowest rate imposed to a third state. "Royalties" encompass payments for the use of copyrights, patents, trademarks, designs, secret formulas, industrial equipment, and information, including payments for motion picture films and television works.

Gains from the Alienation of Property (Article XIII)

Gains from the sale of immovable property can be taxed in the country where the property is located. Gains from the sale of movable property forming part of a PE or fixed base can be taxed in the country where the PE or fixed base is located. Gains from ships and aircrafts will be taxed only in the state of the enterprise. There are specific provisions for gains from shares of companies whose property consists principally of immovable property. Other gains are generally taxable only in the alienator's country of residence, although there's an exception allowing a country to tax gains derived by a former resident within a six-year period.

Professional and Dependent Personal Services (Articles XIV & XV)

Income from professional services (independent activities) is generally taxable only in the individual's country of residence, unless they have a fixed base regularly available in the other country, stay in the other country for more than 183 days, or earn remuneration exceeding a specified amount ($2,500 Canadian dollars or its Philippine peso equivalent, unless otherwise agreed).

Salaries and wages (dependent personal services) are generally taxable only in the country of residence, unless the employment is exercised in the other country.

There are exceptions for short-term employment (less than 183 days) if the remuneration is below a certain threshold or paid by a non-resident employer and not borne by a PE. Remuneration for employment on ships or aircraft in international traffic is taxable only in the enterprise's country of residence.

Other Income Categories (Articles XVI - XXI)

The treaty also addresses:

• Directors' Fees (Article XVI): Taxable in the country where the company is resident.
• Artistes and Athletes (Article XVII): Taxable in the country where the activities are performed, with exceptions for publicly funded visits and non-profit organizations.
• Pensions and Annuities (Article XVIII): Taxable only in the country where they arise, with a limit on the tax on periodic pension payments.
• Government Service (Article XIX): Remuneration, other than a pension, is generally taxable only in the paying country, with exceptions.
• Students (Article XX): Payments for maintenance, education, or training from sources outside the host country are not taxed in the host country.
• Income not Expressly Mentioned (Article XXI): Generally taxable only in the recipient's country of residence, unless derived from sources in the other country.

Avoiding Double Taxation and Other Provisions

Methods for Prevention of Double Taxation (Article XXII)

This article outlines how Canada and the Philippines will avoid double taxation. Canada generally allows a deduction from Canadian tax for taxes paid in the Philippines. For the purpose of the article, tax paid in the Phillipines will be deemed to have been paid at 15%. The Philippines also provides a deduction for taxes paid in Canada, limited to the portion of Philippine tax attributable to the Canadian-sourced income.

Non-Discrimination (Article XXIII)

This article ensures that nationals of one country are not subjected to more burdensome taxation in the other country than nationals of that other country in similar circumstances. It also addresses the taxation of permanent establishments and enterprises owned or controlled by residents of the other country. There are exceptions allowing the Philippines to limit certain tax incentives to its nationals.

Mutual Agreement Procedure (Article XXIV)

This article provides a mechanism for taxpayers to seek resolution if they believe they are being taxed in a way not in accordance with the treaty. They can present their case to the competent authority of their country of residence. The competent authorities of both countries can then consult to resolve the issue and avoid double taxation. There are time limits for addressing such issues.

Exchange of Information (Article XXV)

The competent authorities of Canada and the Philippines are authorized to exchange information necessary for carrying out the treaty and their domestic tax laws, including information to prevent fraud or fiscal evasion. Exchanged information is treated as secret and disclosed only to those involved in tax administration. There are limitations on the obligation to exchange information, protecting trade secrets and information contrary to public policy.

Diplomatic and Consular Officials (Article XXVI)

The treaty does not affect the fiscal privileges of diplomatic and consular officials under international law or special agreements. A member of a diplomatic mission will be considered resident of the sending state. The treaty does not apply to international organizations.

Miscellaneous Rules (Article XXVII)

This article mentions some important points. First, it ensures existing laws and agreements are not restricted by the convention. Second, it validates Canada's imposition of tax related to section 91 of their Income Tax Act. Third, it adresses Phillipines taxing their citizens.

Entry into Force and Termination (Articles XXVIII & XXIX)

The treaty entered into force upon the exchange of instruments of ratification. Its provisions generally took effect for taxes withheld at source and other taxes for taxation years beginning on or after January 1st of the calendar year in which the exchange occurred. The treaty remains in effect indefinitely, but either country can terminate it by giving notice before June 30th of any calendar year after the year of ratification, with termination taking effect in the following calendar year.

Conclusion

The tax treaty between the Philippines and Canada is a comprehensive agreement that addresses a wide range of tax issues affecting individuals and businesses with ties to both countries. By clarifying taxing rights, providing mechanisms for resolving disputes, and facilitating the exchange of information, the treaty promotes cross-border economic activity and helps to prevent double taxation and fiscal evasion. Understanding the treaty's provisions is essential for anyone engaged in business or investment between Canada and the Philippines. The treaty's impact extends beyond simply preventing double taxation; it fosters a more predictable and stable environment for international commerce. It is crucial to always refer to the text, as it is a complex document.

Have you encountered any specific situations where the provisions of this tax treaty have been particularly relevant or challenging?

If you want to know other articles similar to Understanding the Tax Treaty Between the Philippines and Canaday ou can visit the category Tax Deductions.